Article · Market Infrastructure & Settlement
Settlement Finality on a Blockchain: Why a Register Cannot Be Probably True
A register records who owns a security, so on a blockchain it can only record a transfer once settlement finality is reached and the transfer can no longer be reversed or unwound.
A ledger whose finality is probabilistic never reaches that point outright, only a growing likelihood, so the register has to pick a waiting time and live with a residual chance of error1.
Final settlement at ledger close removes that judgement, but it is a technical property: whether the transfer is also final in law depends on the system's rules and the law that governs it1, 6, 7.

In this article
01 · The question
What does settlement finality mean for a register?
Settlement finality is the moment a transfer becomes irrevocable and unconditional, and cannot be unwound even if a party fails. A register states who owns what, so it can only record transfers that have reached that moment1.
A share register is not a ledger of intentions. A fund pays distributions, counts votes, and accepts redemptions on the strength of each entry, so every one of those acts assumes the entry is true.
Settlement finality is what makes it true. The committee of central banks that sets standards for market infrastructure describes it as "the legally defined moment at which the transfer of an asset or financial instrument" is "irrevocable and unconditional and not susceptible to being unwound following the bankruptcy" of a participant1.
In a conventional settlement system that moment is fixed by the system's rules and backed by statute.
When the register moves onto a ledger, the ledger is no longer a copy of the register kept elsewhere. It is the register, and the moment it treats a transfer as done becomes the moment the issuer treats ownership as changed.
The fund on Stellar that this site has written about made a version of that choice: its transfer agent keeps the official record of share ownership in a blockchain-integrated system that uses public networks, with Stellar as the primary one9, 10.
02 · Three kinds of finality
How do different ledgers reach finality?
Ledgers finalise in three broad ways: some become more certain over time without ever reaching a fixed point; some finalise in batches at checkpoints after a delay; and some treat each closed ledger as final at once1, 3, 5.
The first kind is probabilistic. In proof-of-work arrangements, the standard-setters wrote in 2017, "settlement is probabilistic. That is, the more times the transaction is confirmed in the ledger, the less likely it will be revoked"1. Less likely is not never.
A register built on such a ledger has to choose how many confirmations to wait for, and that choice is a risk judgement made by the operator rather than a property of the system.
The second kind arrives at checkpoints. On proof-of-stake Ethereum, time is divided into 12-second slots and 32-slot epochs, and validators vote for pairs of checkpoints. When a pair attracts votes from at least two-thirds of the staked ether, the newer checkpoint becomes justified and the earlier one, already justified, becomes finalised5.
Reversing a finalised block would cost an attacker at least a third of all staked ether5. Because finality is decided at checkpoints, blocks exist for a period before they are final, and the protocol has a mechanism for a chain that fails to finalise for more than four epochs5.
The third kind is final at close. The Stellar Development Foundation describes transactions as "finalized and added to the blockchain once they are agreed upon" by the network's validators, a process it says generally takes about five seconds3.
Its consensus protocol "prioritizes fault tolerance and safety over liveness"4. If validators cannot agree, the ledger waits instead of producing two competing histories.
| Model | When a transfer is final | What the register must decide | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Probabilistic | Never outright; the chance of reversal falls as confirmations accumulate | How many confirmations to wait before recording the transfer | Committee on Payments and Market Infrastructures (CPMI)1 |
| Checkpoint | When an already justified checkpoint is finalised by a two-thirds supermajority vote on the next, between epochs | Whether to record on inclusion or wait for the checkpoint | ethereum.org5 |
| At ledger close | When validators agree the transaction set, generally about five seconds | Nothing further; the closed ledger is the record | Stellar3, 4 |
03 · A fund that trades daily
What does finality at ledger close give a fund that trades daily?
Ledger-close finality makes a fund's register true the moment it is written. Subscriptions, redemptions, and secondary transfers update ownership once, with no interval in which the record is provisional and no waiting rule to set or defend3, 4.
A fund that deals every business day relies on its register for who receives the next distribution, who can vote, and whose redemption is valid, each at a stated moment.
An FMI should provide clear and certain final settlement, at a minimum by the end of the value date.2
The same principle adds that, where necessary or preferable, final settlement should come intraday or in real time2. A register on a probabilistic ledger can meet the end-of-day test in practice by waiting long enough. What it cannot offer is a clear and certain moment, because the moment is the operator's estimate.
One transfer on a register that is final at ledger close

- What does finality at ledger close give a fund that trades daily?
- Step 1: Eligibility checked: The transfer is tested against the holder rules before it is submitted
- Step 2: Submitted: The signed transaction goes to the network
- Step 3: Ledger closes: Validators agree the transaction set, generally within about five seconds ([3])
- Step 4: Register updated: The closed ledger is the record of ownership; nothing remains provisional
For the issuer, a dispute about timing has a single answer. For the holder, a transfer shown on the register is one the network will not later rewrite.
04 · Legal finality
Does a final ledger make a transfer final in law?
Ledger finality alone is not legal finality: in the European Union (EU), a transfer order gains statutory protection against insolvency only inside a system designated under the Settlement Finality Directive. A proposal to extend that protection explicitly to distributed ledger technology (DLT) systems is still in negotiation6, 7.
The standard-setters saw the gap early. In traditional systems, they wrote, finality is "a clear and well-defined point in time, backed by a strong legal basis", while in arrangements that rely on a consensus algorithm "there may not necessarily be a single point of settlement finality", and the law "may not expressly support finality in such cases"1.
The Settlement Finality Directive of 1998 is the EU's answer for conventional systems. It makes transfer orders entered into a designated system before insolvency proceedings open legally enforceable and binding on third parties, with a narrow, conditional extension to orders entered and carried out on the business day the proceedings open.
It also bars a participant or a third party from revoking an order after the moment the system's rules define6.
On 4 December 2025 the Commission proposed replacing the Directive with a regulation7. The proposal says its rules "should be neutral as regards the use of any particular technology", and that references to registers include those "established on DLT"7.
Its Article 21 would let the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) and the European Banking Authority (EBA), working closely with the European System of Central Banks, draft regulatory technical standards that further specify the moments of entry, irrevocability, and final settlement, "including for DLT-based systems"7.
Entry
When a transfer order counts as entered into the system, which fixes whether insolvency protection applies to it6, 7.
Irrevocability
The moment after which neither a participant nor a third party may revoke the order6.
Final settlement
When the transfer is complete. Under the proposal, technical standards could further specify this moment for DLT-based systems7.
As of 7 October 2026, the proposal has not been adopted7. A register on a ledger that is final at close therefore has technical finality today and must find its legal finality in its own documents, its governing law, and, where available, designation.

05 · What it does not establish
What do the sources not establish?
As of 7 October 2026, the CPMI framework, Settlement Finality Directive and Commission proposal read here do not establish a fast ledger's legal finality, that any ledger is safe for a given fund, or what happens to a holding outside the ledger1, 6, 7.
| Question | What the sources say | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Is technical finality legal finality? | No. The legal basis may not expressly support finality on consensus-based arrangements | CPMI1 |
| Does fast settlement bring insolvency protection? | Only inside a designated system under the Directive | Directive6 |
| Will DLT systems get their own finality rules in the EU? | Proposed, with technical standards for DLT-based systems; not adopted | Proposal7 |
| Can an issuer still move a holding after finality? | Yes, where it holds such a power. On Stellar, a clawback acts by a new transaction | Stellar8 |
| Which ledger should a given fund use? | Not addressed by any of these sources | None |
Ledger finality does not mean nothing can happen to a holding. An issuer that enabled clawback on its asset can take that asset back, burning it from the holder's account, by a new and visible transaction8. That is a governed power written into the instrument's terms, and readers should look for it there.
Nor do the sources reach the asset behind the token. Finality closes the question of whether the register changed, not whether the change was lawful, which is the subject of the companion article on which record controls ownership.
Common questions
What else do people ask?
Short answers to the questions people ask most about this topic.
What is probabilistic finality?
Finality that grows with time rather than arriving at a fixed point. In proof-of-work arrangements, the more times a transaction is confirmed in the ledger, the less likely it is to be revoked, but the chance never falls to zero1.
Is Ethereum final?
Ethereum blocks become final at checkpoints. When validators holding at least two-thirds of the staked ether vote for a pair of checkpoints, the newer one is justified and the earlier one is finalised. Reverting a finalised block would cost an attacker at least one-third of all staked ether.
Finality is decided at checkpoints, so it arrives after a delay rather than with each block5.
How quickly is a Stellar transaction final?
The Stellar Development Foundation states that agreement on a transaction set generally takes about five seconds, after which the transactions are permanently added to the ledger3. Its consensus protocol puts safety ahead of liveness, so the network waits rather than risk two different versions of the ledger4.
Does a final ledger mean the issuer can never reverse a holding?
No. Ledger finality means the network will not rewrite its history. An issuer may still have contractual or technical powers over its own asset, such as a clawback, which act through a new transaction rather than by undoing an old one8.
Is a blockchain settlement legally final in the EU?
Only where the law gives it that status. The Settlement Finality Directive protects transfer orders in systems designated under it6. The Commission's proposal of 4 December 2025 would let ESMA and the EBA draft technical standards that further specify finality moments, including for DLT-based systems, but it is a proposal, not law, as of 7 October 20267.
Where should you go next?
The pages below pick up where this one ends. Start with the one closest to where your asset or programme stands today.
- Why the First US-Registered Tokenized Money Market Fund Runs on StellarThe first US-registered money market fund with a public blockchain as its official record runs on Stellar: finality at ledger close, and issuer controls.
- Which Record Controls Ownership of a Tokenized Security?The record that controls a tokenized security is the one the law and documents make official, and in the United States it may be off-chain.
- Settlement & LiquidityHow value settles in the asset each jurisdiction permits: fiat through a licensed provider, swaps without custody, and sales behind an eligibility gate.
- The Securities RegisterHow Registry keeps the register of holders from issuance onwards, performs the transfer-agent function as software, and handles corporate actions.
References
- 1.Committee on Payments and Market Infrastructures, "Distributed ledger technology in payment, clearing and settlement: an analytical framework", February 2017, Section 3.3.2. https://www.bis.org/cpmi/publ/d157.pdf
- 2.Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems and Technical Committee of IOSCO, "Principles for financial market infrastructures", April 2012, Principle 8. https://www.bis.org/publications/principles-financial-market-infrastructures.pdf
- 3.Stellar Development Foundation, "Stellar Consensus Protocol", read 7 October 2026. https://www.stellar.org/learn/stellar-consensus-protocol
- 4.Stellar developer documentation, "Stellar Consensus Protocol (SCP)", read 7 October 2026. https://developers.stellar.org/docs/learn/fundamentals/stellar-consensus-protocol
- 5.ethereum.org, "Proof-of-stake (PoS)", section on finality, read 7 October 2026. https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/consensus-mechanisms/pos/
- 6.Directive 98/26/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 May 1998 on settlement finality in payment and securities settlement systems, Articles 2, 3 and 5. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:31998L0026
- 7.European Commission, Proposal for a Regulation on settlement finality and repealing Directive 98/26/EC, COM(2025) 941 final, 4 December 2025, recitals 6 and 7 and Article 21. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/docs_autres_institutions/commission_europeenne/com/2025/0941/COM_COM(2025)0941_EN.pdf
- 8.Stellar developer documentation, "Control access to an asset", read 7 October 2026. https://developers.stellar.org/docs/tokens/control-asset-access
- 9.Stellar Development Foundation, Franklin Templeton case study, read 7 October 2026. https://stellar.org/case-studies/franklin-templeton
- 10.Franklin Templeton Trust, Franklin OnChain U.S. Government Money Fund, prospectus dated 1 August 2026 (Form N-1A post-effective amendment), "Use of Blockchain" and "Multi-Chain Support and Network Suitability Framework". https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0001786958/000165558926000970/c485bpos.htm
This article is analysis of public sources, not legal advice. Last updated:







